4.3 Aquatic food production systems
Fish and other seafood are a major source of protein for billions of people. Subtopic 4.3 follows that food from the phytoplankton at the base of the food web to the trawler, then asks why so many fish stocks have crashed and what can stop it happening again.
Exam questions often use catch data or a graph of fish stocks over time. You may be asked to explain a collapse, interpret a maximum sustainable yield curve, or evaluate a management strategy such as quotas, marine protected areas or fish farming.
The big ideas
Aquatic food webs and demand
Phytoplankton are the main producers in most aquatic food webs. They are eaten by zooplankton, which are eaten by small fish, and so on up the chain. Many of the fish people like to eat, such as tuna and cod, feed high up, so a lot of energy has already been lost by the time it reaches them. Demand for fish keeps rising as the population grows and as fish are promoted as a healthy food, and better technology such as sonar, bigger nets and larger boats lets fleets catch more than ever.
Overfishing and fishery collapse
Overfishing means taking fish faster than the stock can replace them. Catches may stay high for a while thanks to better technology, then fall suddenly once too few adults are left to breed. The Grand Banks cod fishery off Newfoundland collapsed in the early 1990s, and a fishing ban that followed put tens of thousands of people out of work. Cod numbers stayed low for many years after the ban. Pollution, habitat damage from bottom trawling and climate change, including ocean acidification and coral bleaching, add to the pressure on aquatic populations.
Maximum sustainable yield
Maximum sustainable yield is the largest catch that can be taken year after year without shrinking the stock. It comes from population growth: a stock grows fastest at a middle population size, often around half its carrying capacity. Think of it as living off the interest without touching your savings. Take more than the interest and the savings shrink, and next year's interest is smaller too.
Managing fisheries
Fisheries can be managed with catch quotas, minimum mesh sizes so young fish escape, closed seasons during breeding and limits on the number of boats. Marine protected areas restrict fishing in set parts of the sea, letting stocks recover and spill over into nearby waters. Aquaculture, or fish farming, takes pressure off wild stocks but can cause problems: waste and chemicals pollute the water, disease and escaped fish affect wild populations, coastal habitats such as mangroves are cleared for shrimp ponds, and many farmed fish are fed on wild-caught fish.
For HL students
HL looks at how fish stocks are estimated and why using maximum sustainable yield is risky: stock estimates are uncertain, populations swing naturally, and a target set at the maximum leaves no safety margin. Many scientists prefer a more cautious optimum yield. You also study the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, which gives coastal states control of the fish within 200 nautical miles of their coast, and the ethics of harvesting, such as whaling and the rights of indigenous communities to hunt and fish.
Exam tip
When you explain a fishery collapse, describe the mechanism, not just the cause. "Catches were above the rate of reproduction, so the breeding stock fell until too few adults were left for the population to recover" earns the marks. "They caught too many fish" does not, because it does not explain why the stock could not bounce back.

